New York Budget Deal Includes Auto Insurance Reform With Narrower Serious Injury Rules

New York legislative leaders reached a budget agreement Tuesday on Gov. Kathy Hochul's auto insurance reform package, clearing the largest policy roadblock that has kept the state's spending plan more than a month past its April 1 deadline. Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins confirmed the deal narrows the legal definition of "serious injury," blocks insurers' automatic 5% annual rate hikes, and limits the use of ZIP codes and credit scores in setting premiums.

For New York's roughly 14 million licensed drivers, the announcement signals likely premium relief Hochul has pegged at about $25 a month. Crash victims with traumatic brain injuries and soft-tissue injuries face a tighter path to compensation, and the New York State Trial Lawyers Association joined a group of retired judges who urged lawmakers Tuesday to reject the package.

What the Deal Includes

Stewart-Cousins told reporters the agreement covers "pretty much" all four of Hochul's major budget policy proposals on a conceptual basis, with auto insurance reform joining climate, environmental review changes, and immigration protections in the package. Auto insurance language has not yet been finalized in bill form, though Stewart-Cousins said votes could come the week of May 11.

The biggest change for crash victims is the narrowed eligibility for "serious injury." Under current New York Insurance Law Section 5102, victims qualify if they suffer a fracture, permanent loss of an organ or member, loss of a fetus, a permanent injury, or a medically determined non-permanent injury that disrupts daily life for more than 90 days. The deal eliminates that 90-day non-permanent category, the New York State Trial Lawyers Association said, cutting off pain-and-suffering recovery for many traumatic brain injury and soft-tissue injury victims who don't fit the remaining categories.

On the rating side, insurers will lose the ability to push through a 5% annual increase automatically. Carriers must instead file justifications with the New York Department of Financial Services. NYDFS approved a 21% premium hike as recently as 2024, even though carriers are nominally required to justify increases under existing rules.

The deal also caps insurers' use of certain data points, with ZIP codes and credit scores restricted as rating factors. Implementation language will appear when budget bills drop the week of May 11.

What Hochul Gave Up

Stewart-Cousins confirmed Hochul abandoned her push to change New York's joint-and-several liability rules, the most contested provision in S9005A. Under Hochul's original proposal, drivers found 51% or more responsible for a crash would have lost the right to seek compensation beyond no-fault, and parties under 50% responsible would have escaped paying co-defendants' shares. The MTA had supported the change, with CEO Janno Lieber arguing public agencies face outsized "jackpot payouts" when buses bear single-digit responsibility, but Hochul's office dropped the provision after legislative pushback. Crash victims can still collect full damages from defendants able to pay even when those defendants bear less than 50% responsibility, marking a sharp reversal from the version of the bill that stalled 24 hours earlier.

What This Means for New York Drivers

If you pay New York's average full-coverage premium of $264 per month, per Insurify's March 2026 data, Hochul's projected $25 monthly savings would cut about 9.5% off your bill, or roughly $300 a year. State minimum coverage averages $148 per month, or $1,773 annually, according to Bankrate's May 2026 data, so a comparable percentage cut would deliver about $14 per month for liability-only drivers.

Crash victims face a different math. The $50,000 no-fault personal injury protection threshold stays in place, meaning the first $50,000 of medical bills, lost wages, and other economic losses still flow through your own insurer regardless of fault. Pain-and-suffering damages still require crossing the "serious injury" threshold, which is now harder to clear after the 90-day non-permanent injury category disappears.

Drivers carrying minimum-only liability should ask their agent about adding underinsured motorist coverage. If a future crash leaves you with a TBI or soft-tissue injury that doesn't fit the narrower serious-injury definition, your own UM/UIM policy becomes the main source of recovery beyond the $50,000 PIP cap.

Opposition to the Deal

A group of retired New York judges sent lawmakers a letter Tuesday urging them to reject the package, the New York Law Journal reported, warning crash victims with traumatic brain injuries and soft-tissue injuries would lose meaningful recourse. The judges' letter joins months of opposition from the New York State Trial Lawyers Association, which has called the serious-injury narrowing a giveaway to insurers.

"There will be opportunities for a whole readjustment, and we are hoping that there indeed will be benefits and rebates for those of us who are paying way too much for car insurance," said Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins on Tuesday.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration estimates the societal cost of crashes at $135 billion a year nationwide, a figure trial lawyers cite to argue compensation pathways for victims should be expanded, not contracted. Hochul has countered that fraud and litigation drive New York's premium costs, even as a Streetsblog review of NYDFS statistics found fraud cases far less prevalent than the governor's office has suggested.

How the May Deal Compares to the Stalled April Version

The agreement marks a pivot from last week's reporting, when S9005A appeared dead in the Senate over Stewart-Cousins's objections to the comparative negligence threshold and several rate-setting provisions. Lawmakers passed nine state budget extenders, including the most recent one running through Wednesday, while leaders negotiated. If Hochul signs budget bills after Saturday, May 9, the budget becomes the latest since 2010, per Spectrum News.

Provision	April 2026 Status	May 5 Deal
Narrow "serious injury" definition	Stalled	IN
ZIP code and credit score rating limits	Contested	IN
End automatic 5% annual rate hikes	Contested	IN
51% comparative negligence threshold	Hochul priority	OUT
Joint and several liability rewrite	Hochul priority	OUT

Source: Streetsblog Empire State and Spectrum News reporting, May 5-6, 2026, citing Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins. Final bill language has not been released.

What You Should Do Now

Looking Ahead

Stewart-Cousins flagged budget votes for late next week, with bill language still pending as of Tuesday afternoon. Once enacted, NYDFS will draft regulations implementing the rate-justification rules, the data limits, and the new serious-injury threshold, a process that usually takes 60 to 180 days. Watch for premium filings from State Farm, GEICO, Allstate, and Progressive in the months following enactment, since those four carriers wrote roughly half the New York personal auto market in 2024 per NAIC data, and their rate moves will signal whether Hochul's $25-a-month projection holds.

Frequently Asked Questions