Cheap Car Insurance in Fort Myers, Florida (With 2024 Rates)
Jump to Topic:
Best Car Insurance Companies and Rates Offered
The cheapest car insurance rates in the state are provided by Geico Insurance. The major insurers are State Farm, Progressive and Geico.
Company | Annual premium (50/100/50) | Market share |
---|---|---|
Geico | $750 | 6.6% |
State Farm | $970 | 9.3% |
Allstate | $1,450 | 5.0% |
Progressive | $1,390 | 5.6% |
Get a free quote from the best of 200+ companies in 90 seconds.
Find affordable car insurance in your city
We recommend you to get car insurance quote and compare rates before choosing an insurance plan. People save up to 50% on car insurance by using our comparison shopping.
Insurance Agents in Fort Myers, FL and Near by
-
0 miMr Auto of East Ft Myers4120 Cleveland Ave Ste B1, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 693-1118
-
0 miAcceptance Auto Insurance3946 Cleveland Ave Ste B, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 936-3517
-
0 miWilcox Family Insurance/FED USA Insurance3707 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 337-7755
-
0 miPioneer Insurance2709 Swamp Cabbage Ct Ste 105, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 275-2132
-
0 miEpic Insurance Group3583 Fowler St, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 494-4664
-
0 miBaker Insurance Group3252 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 337-5551
-
0 miThe Insurance Man3049 Cleveland Ave Ste 125, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 334-0777
-
0 miGoosehead Insurance - Jonathan Noda & Elda Gutierrez3049 Cleveland Ave Ste 237, Fort Myers, FL 33901(305) 588-5759
-
0 miJim Gregg Insurance2023 Canal St, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 334-4585
-
0 miInsurance World of SWFL2245 Cleveland Ave Ste 1, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 313-7557
-
0 miClark & Bell Insurance Agency1832 Victoria Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 334-4141
-
0 miThe Thompson Agency Inc2132 Mcgregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 689-8570
-
0 miLott & Gaylor Insurance2120 W First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 337-2221
-
0 miDave Hamrick2070 Mcgregor Blvd Ste 4, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 334-2349
-
0 miMaher Insurance2038 Henley Pl, Fort Myers, FL 33901(941) 337-1322
-
0 miJMR Insurance Group2030 W First St Ste E, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 465-0206
-
0 miDwayne Stevens1542 Carson St, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 344-7414
-
0 miGreat Florida Insurance - Alicia Graham1716 Fowler St, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 672-8194
-
0 miBABB Inc2451 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 333-1320
-
0 miAffordable Secure Insurance2400 First St Ste 303, Fort Myers, FL 33901(239) 288-7936
-
11.09 miMark Ackerman7320 Sanibel Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33967(239) 267-2828
-
11.09 miAckerman Insurance Solutions7320 Sanibel Blvd Ste B, Fort Myers, FL 33967(239) 267-1515
-
11.09 miTeri Riley7021 Constitution Blvd Ste 3, Fort Myers, FL 33967(239) 267-2022
-
13.39 miTed Todd Insurance10676 Colonial Blvd Ste 20, Fort Myers, FL 33913(239) 768-7000
-
13.39 miBacarella Insurance Group11300 Lindbergh Blvd Ste 102, Fort Myers, FL 33913(239) 334-2442
-
13.39 miHome Run Insurance13720 Jetport Commerce Pkwy Ste 11, Fort Myers, FL 33913(239) 768-8163
-
13.39 miDavid Anthony Insurance Agency12331 Towne Lake Dr Ste 1 & 2, Fort Myers, FL 33913(239) 561-2223
-
2.61 miVTC Insurance Group - Valenti Trobec & Woody4110 Center Pointe Dr Ste 215, Fort Myers, FL 33916(239) 275-8226
-
2.61 miFiesta Auto Insurance4115 Palm Beach Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33916(239) 288-7440
-
2.61 miEdison Insurance Group3835 Palm Beach Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33916(239) 693-0400
-
2.61 miE & B Associates1960 Velasco St Ste J3, Fort Myers, FL 33916(239) 337-7115
-
3.93 miGreat Scot! Insurance12155 Metro Pkwy Ste 28a, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 561-3400
-
3.93 miM & M Insurance Services12541 Metro Pkwy Ste 6, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 269-9098
-
3.93 miWe Insure - Chalimar Assis10231 Metro Pkwy Ste 104, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 313-2045
-
3.93 miFHC Insurance3441 Colonial Blvd Ste 7, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 936-0108
-
3.93 miKaren Wolfe3441 Colonial Blvd Ste 6, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 936-0027
-
3.93 miTim Shaw Insurance4091 Colonial Blvd Ste 100, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 939-1010
-
3.93 miAcentria Insurance4091 Colonial Blvd Ste 101, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 939-4414
-
3.93 miRosemary Steadman4391 Colonial Blvd Ste 121, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 936-6800
-
3.93 miBrightway Insurance - Debbie Hubicki and Diane Haas4391 Colonial Blvd Ste 103, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 931-5390
-
3.93 miWay Better Insurance4978 Royal Gulf Cir, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 210-7720
-
3.93 miIron Ridge Insurance Services4971 Royal Gulf Cir, Fort Myers, FL 33966(800) 775-8526
-
3.93 miState Insurance USA9377 6 Mile Cypress Pkwy Ste 115, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 567-9992
-
3.93 miMichele Losapio7950 Dani Dr Ste 145, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 332-4999
-
3.93 miHerndon Carr & Co10501 6 Mile Cypress Pkwy Ste 101, Fort Myers, FL 33966(239) 939-1996
-
3.96 miLykes Insurance5216 Summerlin Commons Blvd Ste 200, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 931-5600
-
3.96 miRobertson Ryan & Associates5260 Summerlin Commons Way Ste 301, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 278-1700
-
3.96 miBaldwin Krystyn Sherman5237 Summerlin Commons Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 332-0247
-
3.96 miZehner & Associates5268 Summerlin Commons Way Ste 502, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 433-2325
-
3.96 miRegency Insurance Group5248 Red Cedar Dr Ste 103, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 634-4344
-
3.96 miBest One Insurance12553 New Brittany Blvd # 32, Fort Myers, FL 33907(954) 944-3928
-
3.96 miLutgert Insurance12660 World Plaza Ln Bldg 73, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 936-5622
-
3.96 miEstrella Insurance11150 S Cleveland Ave Ste 110, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 271-3570
-
3.96 miInsurance Agency of Erik Ginkinger12730 New Brittany Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 275-9544
-
3.96 miStewart & Sons Insurance8548 Crystal Ct, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 936-8844
-
3.96 miCampbell Insurance Company12800 University Dr Ste 200, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 689-7203
-
3.96 miAAAA Discount Auto Insurance5240 Bank St Ste 3, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 694-0000
-
3.96 miAvalon Insurance Group7370 College Pkwy Ste 312, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 275-3888
-
3.96 miDirect General Auto Insurance5100 S Cleveland Ave Ste 317, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 418-0199
-
3.96 miFirst Family Insurance7800 University Pointe Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33907(800) 327-0977
-
3.96 miFiesta Auto Insurance12575 S Cleveland Ave Ste 2, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 313-6560
-
3.96 miHuff Insurance & Financial Services13241 University Dr Ste 102, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 333-4833
-
3.96 miGary L Green1400 Colonial Blvd Ste 12, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 939-2112
-
3.96 miSylvester Insurance12995 S Cleveland Ave Ste 111, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 267-9200
-
3.96 miDickerson Insurance Agency12995 S Cleveland Ave Ste 1, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 433-0494
-
3.96 miLarry Snider12995 S Cleveland Ave Ste 103b, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 561-8599
-
3.96 miFreedom Insurance Center12995 S Cleveland Ave Ste 141, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 939-2886
-
3.96 miCulbertson Agency13550 Reflections Pkwy Ste 5-502, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 210-7700
-
3.96 miBB&T - Oswald Trippe & Company13515 Bell Tower Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 433-4535
-
3.96 miGreat Florida Insurance - Linda Blackmon7051 Cypress Ter Ste 201, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 433-2800
-
3.96 miAAA Insurance2516 Colonial Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 939-6500
-
3.96 miThe Martel Agency15050 Elderberry Lane Ste 4-7, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 939-9991
-
3.96 miDavison Insurance15050 Elderberry Ln Ste 4, Fort Myers, FL 33907(239) 703-7792
-
4.71 miEdison Insurance Services6325 Presidential Ct Ste 1a, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 267-4042
-
4.71 miBouchard Insurance8191 College Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 489-3232
-
4.71 miBrightway Insurance of Fort Myers8660 College Pkwy Ste 300, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 466-8050
-
4.71 miSouthwest Florida Insurance Associates8695 College Pkwy Ste 160, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 489-1212
-
4.71 miJill Wedeles Caile8841 College Pkwy Ste 103, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 482-7804
-
4.71 miLudden Insurance Agency8931 Conference Dr Ste 7, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 437-5800
-
4.71 miTerry A Keith Agency8931 Conference Dr Ste 4, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 482-3040
-
4.71 miSutton & Associates Insurance Agency1361 Royal Palm Square Blvd Ste 5, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 939-7303
-
4.71 miKevin G. Lewis1430 Royal Palm Square Blvd Ste 102, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 936-5100
-
4.71 miSawyer Insurance1412 Royal Palm Square Blvd Ste 104, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 275-0700
-
4.71 miWe Insure - Richard Hassad4575 Via Royale, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 344-7002
-
4.71 miOlde Florida Insurance6719 Winkler Rd Ste 114, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 333-0711
-
4.71 miCharlie Dodson9541 Cypress Lake Drive Suite A, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 433-2139
-
4.71 miRay Hair9541 Cypress Lake Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 995-0202
-
4.71 miWunderlin & Associates13601 Mcgregor Blvd Ste 15, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 226-0800
-
4.71 miNash Insurance & Associates8801 College Pkwy Ste 1 & 5, Fort Myers, FL 33919(239) 333-0888
-
6.94 miBrown & Brown of Florida6611 Orion Dr Ste 201, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 274-1444
-
6.94 miBrian Glaeser6700 Daniels Pkwy Ste 2, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 334-6050
-
6.94 miFive County Insurance Agency14120 Metropolis Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 939-1400
-
6.94 miFlorida Farm Bureau Insurance14180 Metropolis Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 561-5100
-
6.94 miZeeshan Salehjee6900 Daniels Pkwy Ste 7, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 561-1970
-
6.94 miInsurance & Risk Management Services14440 Metropolis Ave Ste 103, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 275-0151
-
6.94 miSusan Fahs14421 Metropolis Ave Ste 105, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 939-9972
-
6.94 miAWA Insurance13700 Six Mile Cypress Pkwy Ste 1, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 418-1100
-
6.94 miS&S Insurance Solutions of Florida13420 Parker Commons Blvd Ste 105, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 344-0023
-
6.94 miStatewide Insurance Markets #38024 Alico Rd Ste A7, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 437-6444
-
6.94 miNick Glaeser13500 Powers Ct Ste 201, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 338-3410
-
6.94 miCathy L. Sink13650 Fddlstcks Blvd Ste 203, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 561-8600
-
6.94 miBrightway Insurance - Tyler Smith & Chris Mitchell9230 Daniels Pkwy Ste 102, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 603-8200
-
6.94 miGulfshore Insurance9530 Marketplace Rd Ste 205, Fort Myers, FL 33912(239) 261-3646
-
8.02 miBest Insurance4392 Palm Beach Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905(239) 694-6357
-
8.02 miGreat Florida Insurance - Brian LaRiviere4901 Palm Beach Blvd Ste 39, Fort Myers, FL 33905(239) 694-2886
-
8.02 miParker-Douglas Insurance9160 Forum Corporate Pkwy Ste 350, Fort Myers, FL 33905(239) 244-9813
-
8.02 miCathy Sink11841 Palm Beach Blvd Unit 111, Fort Myers, FL 33905(239) 693-2255
-
8.02 miArt Roberts13102 Palm Beach Blvd Ste B, Fort Myers, FL 33905(239) 693-6468
-
8.02 miA+ Dependable Insurance Agency14078 Palm Beach Blvd Ste C, Fort Myers, FL 33905(239) 558-5093
-
8.02 miThe Keats Agency4111 Otter Bend Cir, Fort Myers, FL 33905(239) 309-0735
-
9.21 miMetro Insurance Agency15200 S Tamiami Trl Ste 117, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 466-8600
-
9.21 miJeremy Henley15245 S Tamiami Trl Ste 11, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 433-3117
-
9.21 miFrank Aiello15245 S Tamiami Trl Ste 11, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 777-9992
-
9.21 miTracey Coppin9671 Gladiolus Dr Ste 105, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 489-2442
-
9.21 miLisa Adams15880 Summerlin Rd Ste 306, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 433-3383
-
9.21 miDanis Insurance15065 Mcgregor Blvd Ste 109, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 939-7697
-
9.21 miInsurance Megastore16050 S Tamiami Trl, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 225-6342
-
9.21 miConnect Insurance Agency16518 Whispering Trace Ct, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 432-5454
-
9.21 miJulie Keating16681 Mcgregor Blvd Ste 203, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 466-1500
-
9.21 miIndependent Insurance Solutions16048 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 454-0931
-
9.21 miStability Insurance Group16521 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 466-7594
-
9.21 miDirect General Auto Insurance18911 S Tamiami Trl Ste 12, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 267-1064
-
9.21 miCentennial Insurance Services17595 S Tamiami Trl Ste 107, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 247-5125
-
9.21 miRedish Insurance Agency16970 S Tamiami Trl Ste 2, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 303-4412
-
9.21 miThe Insurancenter16591 S Tamiami Trl, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 489-2838
-
9.21 miAnn Clark16440 S Tamiami Trl Ste 9, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 433-7771
-
9.21 miSihle Insurance Group6010 Forest Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 707-0409
-
9.21 miPrivate Client Insurance Services9736 Commerce Center Ct, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 481-1949
-
9.21 miInsurance Agency of SW FL11595 Kelly Carlos Center #110, Fort Myers, FL 33908(239) 454-1866
Learn More About Car Insurance in Fort Myers, FL
Methodology
The insurance rates mentioned in this article is based on the average amount for a 30 year old female purchasing 50/100/50 ($50,000 for injury liability for one person, $100,000 for all injuries and $50,000 for property damage in an accident) liability car insurance coverage. The premium rate can be higher or lower than the rates specified depending on the type of coverage one may choose, deductibles applied and the discounts offered by insurance company.