Car Ads Pushed Speed Twice as Often as Safety, IIHS Finds, While Speeding Tickets Add $525 a Year

Car ads promoted performance themes such as speed, power, and traction more than twice as often as safety, according to a new Insurance Institute for Highway Safety analysis released May 12, 2026. The cultural messaging carries a direct wallet consequence for U.S. drivers: a single speeding conviction raises auto insurance rates by an average of 24%, or roughly $525 a year.

What the IIHS Study Found

IIHS Research Scientist Amber Woods and her co-authors reviewed more than 1,500 television ads aired in 2018, 2020, and 2022, plus 1,000 internet and social media ads from 2020 and 2022. Ten coders at the University of Virginia media studies department classified each spot against 23 marketing themes, then weighted the results by Nielsen Ad Intel spending data to reflect actual viewer exposure.

Performance was the single most common theme across the dataset, appearing in 43% of weighted ads. Safety appeared in just 8%. About 16% of ads showed speed or speeding directly, and 28% emphasized traction, often through footage of vehicles kicking up dust on dirt tracks or rumbling over boulders. Fewer than 1 in 10 traction-themed ads paired that capability with a crash-avoidance message.

The trend worsened during the study window. Speed-focused ads climbed from 14% in 2018 to 19% in 2022, traction-focused ads rose from 20% to 38%, and safety-focused ads collapsed from 11% to 3%. SUV ads themed around performance jumped from 28% to 45% over the same period, while sedan advertising leaned hardest on raw velocity: 47% of sedan ads in 2020 used speed themes, against 11% for SUV ads and 5% for pickup ads.

"Advertising like this has helped normalize speeding, masking how dangerous it is," said Amber Woods, the study's lead author and an IIHS research scientist. "Just think about how different attitudes are toward speeding versus impaired driving."

The Wallet Cost of Speeding

NHTSA early estimates put U.S. traffic deaths at 39,345 in 2024, with speeding linked to 11,288 of them. For drivers who survive the stop, the financial penalty arrives at renewal.

LendingTree analyzed insurance quote data and found a single conviction for going 11 to 15 mph over the limit raises full-coverage premiums by 22.7% on average, equal to $524.74 per year or $43.73 per month. ValuePenguin pegs the national bump at roughly 24% in 2026 data, with the rate stickier than most drivers realize: violations typically remain on insurance records for about three years before they roll off most carriers' rating windows.

Severity multiplies the penalty. ValuePenguin data shows a ticket for 1 to 10 mph over the limit triggers a 30% rate jump on average, while convictions for 30+ mph over push the average increase to 49%. A driver convicted of reckless or aggressive driving, both common in states where the cited speed exceeds the posted limit by 25 mph or more, can see premium hikes north of 70%.

Speeding Ticket Insurance Hikes by State

Geography reshapes the penalty more than almost any other factor. A driver cited in San Diego pays a vastly different price than a driver cited in Buffalo, even on the same vehicle and clean prior record.

State	Premium Increase After Ticket	Annual Dollar Hike
California	+42%	+$1,005
Florida	+12.4%	+$421
New York	+7%	+$293
National Average	+22.7%	+$525

Source: LendingTree analysis of full-coverage quotes for a 30-year-old driver cited at 11-15 mph over the limit, compared against a clean-record baseline; published 2026. New York dollar figure estimated from the state baseline of $4,192 reported by Insurance.com.

Florida drivers can see city-level rates on our Florida car insurance page, and California residents can read the broader rate-environment context in our analysis of California's 2025 rate hikes. For drivers fighting a citation or budgeting around the renewal jump, our guide to car insurance after a speeding ticket walks through carrier-by-carrier math.

Sports Cars Carry Their Own Premium

The cars featured in the high-octane ads cost more to insure even when the owner never gets a ticket. Full-coverage insurance on a sports car averages $1,726 a year, roughly 32% more than the typical sedan, based on InsureMojo rate analysis. Premiums swing from about $1,004 a year for a Nissan 350Z to $2,315 for a BMW i8, with horsepower, theft frequency, and parts complexity driving the spread.

Carrier choice matters more on a fast car than almost anywhere else in auto insurance. A driver insuring a BMW i8 with Progressive pays roughly $193 per month, while the same coverage from Farmers runs $359, a $1,992 annual gap on identical risk. Model-by-model averages live in our sports car insurance breakdown.

Telematics Programs Watch Hard Acceleration

The advertising message that you should drive aggressively collides with how modern insurance actually prices risk. Progressive reports about 20% of Snapshot users see rate increases after the trial period, with hard braking and rapid acceleration among the top scoring penalties. Allstate Drivewise can also push rates upward for unsafe driving, tracking speeding, hard braking, and late-night trips.

Discount-only programs from State Farm, Nationwide, USAA, Farmers, and American Family avoid the rate-hike risk, though aggressive acceleration still costs participants the discount they could have earned, typically 10% to 30%. Our telematics program comparison details which carriers can raise rates and which cannot.

Why U.S. Car Ads Push Speed

Other countries restrict what carmakers can show on screen. The United Kingdom advertising code prohibits ads that encourage dangerous driving and explicitly limits messaging about power, acceleration, or handling unless the context clearly relates to safety, such as a swerve to avoid a crash. U.S. broadcasters set their own standards, and the IIHS team found those standards loose enough to be functionally unenforceable.

ViacomCBS, now Paramount, banned "risky behavior portrayed positively" without defining risky behavior. NBCUniversal required "compliance with standard safety precautions" while calling out seat belts but ignoring speed. ABC asked for "safe and lawful driving practices" without any reference to speed limits in the standards examples.

"This study highlights the cultural dimension of our road safety crisis," said IIHS President David Harkey. "Automakers and broadcasters need to start treating unsafe speed the same way they would drunk driving or failure to use a seat belt."

Harkey's framing echoes IIHS's push on enforcement; see our coverage of how stronger seat belt laws could save 277 more lives a year and reduce loss-cost pressure on premiums.

What You Should Do Now

Looking Ahead

IIHS plans to extend the content analysis to 2024 and 2026 ad data, Woods told reporters. With NHTSA's 2025 fatality estimates due later this summer, regulators and state insurance departments will be watching whether the 3.8% decline in U.S. road deaths between 2023 and 2024 holds or reverses.

Frequently Asked Questions