U.S. News Names GEICO Best Overall in Inaugural 2026-2027 Car Insurance Awards

U.S. News & World Report on Wednesday rolled out its first-ever Car Insurance Awards, handing GEICO the Best Overall trophy and splitting four subcategory wins among Travelers, Progressive, USAA, and Nationwide. The publication said its scoring blends NAIC Complaint Index data with proprietary consumer surveys covering claims, value, and service across roughly a dozen national carriers.

Drivers shopping coverage in 2026 now have a fresh authority list to compare against J.D. Power, Bankrate, and NerdWallet rankings. The catch: only five carriers won, and three of the most-quoted national insurers (State Farm, Allstate, and Farmers) walked away with no award at all.

Who Won What

The five award categories are tied to specific consumer-experience metrics, not generic "best of" labels. GEICO took Best Overall on the strength of its rating breadth and discount lineup, which U.S. News flagged as the largest among insurers it reviewed. Travelers won Best for Low Complaints, citing its below-average grievance volume at state insurance departments and a 4.9 U.S. News rating, the highest of any winner.

Progressive earned Most Likely to be Renewed based on survey responses about loyalty and intent-to-renew. USAA repeated its long-running pattern in third-party rankings by taking Best for the Military Community, with a $1,487 average annual rate that beat every other winner by at least $352. Nationwide rounded out the list as Best for Customer Service, despite carrying the highest average rate in the lineup at $2,418.

Carrier	Award	U.S. News Rating	Average Annual Rate
GEICO	Best Overall	4.8 / 5	$1,925
Travelers	Best for Low Complaints	4.9 / 5	$1,839
Progressive	Most Likely to be Renewed	4.7 / 5	$1,916
USAA	Best for the Military Community	4.6 / 5	$1,487
Nationwide	Best for Customer Service	4.5 / 5	$2,418

Source: U.S. News & World Report Insurance Awards database, published May 7, 2026. Average annual rates reflect U.S. News national averages across multiple driver profiles; individual quotes vary by state, vehicle, and driving record.

Why Each Winner Took Its Category

GEICO's Best Overall win reflects three specific data inputs U.S. News weighed: the broadest discount stack of any rated insurer, a usage-based program (DriveEasy) that personalizes rates by driving behavior, and below-average NAIC complaint volume in the most recent reporting year. Buyers comparing GEICO can review our full GEICO auto insurance review for state availability, claims experience, and discount-by-discount breakdowns.

Travelers picked up Best for Low Complaints despite selling fewer policies than GEICO or Progressive. The carrier's NAIC Complaint Index sits below 1.0, meaning state regulators receive fewer grievances than expected for its market size. Travelers also offers rideshare coverage and accident forgiveness, though both are state-restricted. See our Travelers auto insurance review for the full discount and add-on list.

Progressive's Most Likely to be Renewed award traces back to U.S. News survey respondents, with most saying they would renew their policy and recommend the carrier. Snapshot, Progressive's telematics program, drives the loyalty: safe drivers see discounts at renewal, though high-risk drivers can see rates climb. Detailed breakdowns are in our Progressive auto insurance review.

USAA's $1,487 average annual rate is roughly 23% lower than GEICO's $1,925 and 39% lower than Nationwide's $2,418. The trade-off is eligibility: only active military, veterans, and immediate family members qualify. Active-duty members can also stack a discount for garaging vehicles on a military base. Compare rates and coverage in our USAA auto insurance review.

Nationwide won Best for Customer Service while carrying the lineup's highest average rate. The carrier's add-ons matter here: vanishing deductible, accident forgiveness, and pay-per-mile coverage through SmartMiles. Nationwide does not sell auto insurance in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, or Massachusetts. Coverage details and state availability are in our Nationwide auto insurance review.

Who Is Missing From the List

State Farm, the largest auto insurer in the U.S. by market share, did not win any of the five awards. Neither did Allstate, Liberty Mutual, or Farmers, four carriers that combined insure tens of millions of vehicles. The omissions matter for shoppers, because U.S. News only ranks carriers it rates, and the Best Overall pick may not be available or competitively priced in every ZIP code.

Drivers in states where State Farm and Allstate dominate market share, including Illinois, Iowa, and Texas, will still need broader comparison tools. Read our State Farm auto insurance review and Allstate auto insurance review to see how those carriers stack up on discounts and claims, even though they are not in the U.S. News awards lineup.

How the Methodology Works

U.S. News built its scoring on three pillars: customer satisfaction, company and service features, and cost. Customer satisfaction inputs come from proprietary consumer surveys covering claims handling, value perception, and service quality. Company features cover coverage options, discount stacks, and policy availability. Cost weighs baseline premiums and ranges across diverse driver archetypes.

The methodology also incorporates NAIC Complaint Index data and policyholder retention figures. NAIC complaint scores below 1.0 indicate fewer grievances than expected for the carrier's size. Retention data captures whether existing customers stick around at renewal, a leading indicator of service quality and pricing fairness. The full methodology is published at usnews.com/insurance/methodology.

What This Means for 2026 Shoppers

The awards landed in the middle of a record auto insurance shopping cycle. Insurify reported in early 2026 that 33% of U.S. drivers plan to switch carriers this year, the highest share since the company began tracking switching intent. Average premiums climbed roughly 10% across 2024-2025 before stabilizing in early 2026, pushing more drivers to comparison-shop.

For drivers already with one of the five winners, the awards confirm what J.D. Power and NAIC data have shown: each carrier excels at one specific dimension. For drivers using a non-winner like State Farm or Allstate, the awards offer a benchmark. Compare the discount stack, NAIC complaint score, and average rate of your current carrier against the relevant winner before renewing.

Shoppers who want a starting point by state can begin with the relevant state hub. Florida residents, for example, can check our Florida car insurance page for city-level rates and carrier availability. Texas residents should review our Texas car insurance page for the lowest-cost carriers in the state.

What You Should Do Now

Frequently Asked Questions